Probably nobody here gives a rat's ass about my opinion, but anyway:
The whole thing boils down to three questions:
1. Do people realize that, "unmoderated" does NOT mean the same as "anything goes"?
2. On whose terms will this site be run: the level-headed majority who want a place to chat, discuss, and debate; or a few professional troublemakers who have a problem with any kind of authority?
3. Will there ever develop a culture of peer control for keeping the troublemakers at bay - that people really dare to say when somebody has gone too far, and that the person in question will also take heed of it?
If a romper room for the anarchists is what you want, go ahead and make this site one, by all means; but, in that case, you can count me out for good - I got enough of trollfests on my time on the IMDb forums.