I don't think so, sf. I believe you, actually, so there is no need (on my behalf) for you to post your PMs with Voronwe or the post from hal. (This is a messageboard, not a court of law.) I just think you should always ask the other person involved in your PMs before posting their contents here, especially if it's their writings and not yours--and especially if it's a delicate matter. It'd be one thing to post, "SF told me in a PM that it was your birthday today, so Happy Birthday!" It's another thing entirely to divulge private communication of a disciplinary nature from another board.
But if the other jurors feel differently and want to see the evidence for themselves, then we'll go from there.
Lali