I chose "other", because I was raised atheist, mellowed to agnostic over the years, and then started exploring the ideas behind lots of other religions.
Most of the one's I've read about seem to have one or two interesting concepts that ring true for me, and when that happens I add the idea to my own personal, developing theory about the nature of life, the universe and everything.
I tend to respect more the religions that offer explanations and methods of dealing with "chi" flow and usage, and more dismissive of those that decry such things as evil.
Energy/self healing is real, and suppressing information regarding it is wrong and harmful in my opinion.
It seems to me that throughout the ages, there occasionally pops up a person who correctly intuits some part of the nature of reality and has the charisma to pass on that knowledge sucessfully to interested parties. And then a lot of other, extraneous stuff is slapped onto the original idea, and people muck up the original message with their own interpretations and ideas, and pretty soon you have a belief system with a core of Truth and a halo of not so good ideas hitching a ride along with it. And then later, the whole package of ideas is accepted as Truth, and that causes all the problems.
Every religion I've read about so far has a core of "truth" that rings true for me. (Except Satanism, that was just icky!) It's just that people get so bound up in the small print added afterwards that they can't get along with others that have different small print.
At this point in my life, I could no more choose a single religion and stick to it than I could stick to a single food and eat it for the rest of my life. All religions are nourishing, but the flavors and nutritional content vary.
I probably lean more towards Paganism and various Oriental philosophies than anything else, simply because some of their premises are easily tested and provable, which lends credence to the other ideas held by those belief systems.